Quietly Undoing a Deed Transfer to a Family Member After Adding Them to the Deed? That’s a Crime.

A mother tries to take a deed away from her son. It’s the mother’s own property, located in Broward County, Florida. She had added her son to the deed years ago. Records at the appraiser’s office show that the home has three bedrooms and two and a half baths. The mother bought it back in 1994 and then included her son as a joint owner.

Now, it’s true that a joint ownership can be broken by a quitclaim deed. But the joint owners have to agree. One joint owner can’t slip a transfer to themselves without the other’s agreement.

The mother evidently didn’t want to bother with legal formalities. Almost 30 years after buying this home, she falsified her son’s signature on a quitclaim to herself. And a lawyer tried to help. All three people know each other.

When something like this happens, are there consequences? Certainly so. As a recent case in South Florida illustrates, serious punishment can follow.

Oh, What a Tangled Web They Wove

A young attorney, Ashley M., assisted Suzanne C., a senior citizen in Hollywood, Florida, to take the home from Suzanne’s son, Ryan S. The victim in this case, Ryan, is an attorney in Fort Lauderdale. He’s Ashley’s now-former employer.

The case documents show a number of troubling details:

  • The young lawyer, Ashley, worked for the victim at his Fort Lauderdale law office.
  • Ryan’s mother one day asked her to go out to lunch and then take her on a string of errands, including a stop at the local UPS branch to have a document notarized.
  • Ryan’s mother, Suzanne, asked the young lawyer, Ashley, to get her a quitclaim deed. The deed, Suzanne falsely told Ashley, was meant to transfer a home in another state.
  • Then the young lawyer drove with Suzanne to a local library, where she signed up for and was issued a library card, enabling the use of library equipment. Ashley used a computer and printed a quitclaim deed from a file she’d created beforehand, at the law office.

Mission accomplished: Suzanne had the requested deed.

It was a forgery. Suzanne’s son’s signature was added using a signature stamp that was taken from her son’s desk. The deed transferred the home from Suzanne and her son to Suzanne as the sole named owner.

Suzanne went to the county recorder’s office to file the document. She didn’t succeed. The recorder’s office pointed out that the document was a printed copy, not the original deed.

And then Suzanne called the young lawyer again. Would Ashley bring her the original paperwork? Yes. Ashley would.

Aftermath: Attempts to Backtrack and Admission

After a deed forgery in the county records came to light, another quitclaim deed was filed to put the ownership back in the right hands. But this did not turn back time. It did not absolve Ryan’s mother and his employee.

The young lawyer said she did carry out the actions. She told the court that she didn’t understand what she was doing was wrong at the time. Ashley claimed she didn’t know she was dealing with a document Ryan’s mother had forged. She told the disciplinary court that she had not looked through the papers Suzanne left in her car—the documents Suzanne asked her to bring to the county office.

Nevertheless, Ashley admitted to having drafted the deed. And that deed ended up in the county records.

Ashley said she was manipulated by her boss’s mother. She told the Florida Bar disciplinary court that she ought to have applied better judgment and diligence. Because the fact is, a mother was swindling her son, a Fort Lauderdale lawyer—and the lawyer who worked for him was aiding deed theft. 

Co-Defendants Sentenced to Four Years on Probation for Falsifying a Deed

Both the mother and the young lawyer who assisted with the deed transfer were arrested. Both of them were criminally charged. Both of them ended up with four years of probation in criminal court.

Outside of the mother’s misguided attitude about co-ownership of a home, the most troubling factor here is that a legal professional would assist in a deed crime.

The young lawyer pleaded “no contest” to the charges against her:

  • Unlawful Filing of False Documents Against Real Property.
  • Criminal Use of Personal Identification Information.

Each of these crimes is third-degree felonies in Florida.

Ashley’s sentence was four years of probation. She acknowledged that she and Suzanne acted to defraud the victim by having a deed recorded to take him off the home’s title. She further acknowledged that Ryan’s signature stamp was used for this activity, without his knowledge. But she claimed she didn’t know.

In any case, the mother and the young lawyer have criminal records for an incident that involved filing false documents and impersonation.

Lawyer Gets a Year-Long Suspension From Law Practice

There was also a professional disciplinary case for the young attorney. The judge for the disciplinary case at the Florida Bar originally said the lawyer should get a slap on the wrist: suspension for 90 days. That judge found that the lawyer was remorseful and had not acted out of personal motives or dishonesty.

Indeed, the young lawyer admitted responsibility in the case. But she claimed that Suzanne had manipulated her.

“I should have known better,” Ashley admitted.

The decision of the judge in the disciplinary case then went to the Supreme Court of Florida. That court overrode the 90-day suspension and replaced it with a full year off from practice.

Why? The Supreme Court was unconvinced by Ashley’s claim to have been fooled by her boss’s mother. Why not ask questions, hit pause, and save a lot of legal trouble for everyone involved? Why act in a way that burdens the Florida legal system’s resources?

With this more severe suspension, more severe consequences follow. Before petitioning for reinstatement, the young lawyer will have to be evaluated by the Florida Bar. A lawyer suspended for 91 or more days must go through an intense vetting process in order to resume lawyering.

Ashley’s suspension was announced by the Florida Bar on October 1, 2026, following a September 11 order of the Florida high court.

Transfer Remorse: A Parent’s Regret for Adding an Adult Child to the Deed

It looks like what’s happened here is a case of transfer remorse—taken to extremes.

So, dear readers, pause and reflect on whether you really want to add an adult child to your deed. If you have second thoughts later, you may not remove someone from your deed without their consent. Even if you bought the home yourself. And forging a family member’s signature? That’s just as illegal as falsifying the signature of an unrelated person.

Supporting References

The Florida Bar Disciplinary Actions, Case No. SC2024-1828 (Oct. 1, 2026).

David J. Neal for the Miami Herald (McClatchy): Mom Tried to Steal Real Estate From Her Son. A South Florida Attorney Helped (published Oct. 11 and updated Oct. 13, 2026). Story also published by the Tampa Bay Times on Oct. 11, 2026.

And as linked.

Photo credit: VicFury via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC-BY SA 4.0 International.